When Tiah McCreary purchased a used Kia K5 from Taylor Kia of Lima, she thought she was driving away in her new journey for good. As an alternative, the dealership repossessed the automobile only a month later. That might have been the top of the story.
However McCreary observed one thing the supplier apparently didn’t: Taylor Kia of Lima had didn’t renew the registration for its personal enterprise identify with the state of Ohio. So she did what any scorned, resourceful buyer would possibly dream of doing: she registered the dealership’s identify for herself.
Then, she despatched the supplier a cease-and-desist letter.
Now, an appeals court docket is siding together with her on at the very least one a part of the dispute, and the case is headed again to an Ohio courtroom.
Do not miss
How a automobile buy became a authorized saga
McCreary’s uncommon story started in February 2024, when she visited Taylor Kia of Lima to purchase a 2022 Kia K5, in response to court docket filings. Like most automobile patrons, she signed a thick stack of paperwork — together with a binding arbitration clause that mentioned any disputes associated to the acquisition can be dealt with outdoors the courtroom.
She left the lot with a automobile and a mortgage provisionally accepted by International Lending Companies.
However that mortgage approval didn’t stick. The lender later determined McCreary’s earnings info wasn’t ample, and the dealership repossessed the Kia whereas she was at work.
For many individuals, that’s the place the nightmare would finish, with a repossessed automobile and a bruised credit score report. However McCreary began trying into authorized choices and discovered a golden nugget: Taylor Kia of Lima had let its commerce identify registration lapse with the Ohio Secretary of State.
She filed for the identify herself.
Then, she took the following step: suing the dealership and its dad or mum firm for fraud, unjust enrichment, and violations of Ohio’s Client Gross sales Practices Act. On prime of that, she demanded they cease doing enterprise beneath the identify “Taylor Kia of Lima,” as a result of in response to state data, it now belonged to her.
Arbitration, appeals and a twist
At first, the dealership fought again by pointing to the arbitration settlement McCreary had signed. A decrease court docket agreed with them and tossed her lawsuit, ruling the dispute ought to go to arbitration as an alternative of open court docket. However the Third District Court docket of Appeals noticed it in another way. Earlier this month, the court docket dominated that whereas the arbitration clause coated the automobile buy, it didn’t apply to the battle over the dealership’s identify, as a result of trademark and trade-name rights don’t have anything to do together with her mortgage or the repossession.
“This declare is a separate matter that may very well be pursued independently of the opposite claims within the criticism,” the court docket wrote.
Meaning McCreary’s revenge-by-paperwork will get its day in court docket in any case.
Learn extra: Nervous in regards to the inventory market in 2025? Discover out how one can entry this $1B non-public actual property fund (with as little as $10)
May you pull off a transfer like this?
Whereas McCreary’s case is uncommon, it’s a reminder that companies should sustain with the boring paperwork that protects their names, emblems, and reputations. In the event that they don’t, opportunists, and even indignant prospects, would possibly step in.
However don’t anticipate this to be a straightforward win for McCreary. The dealership might argue that its long-standing use of the identify provides it precedence beneath trademark legislation, even when the state-level registration lapsed. Authorized consultants say courts usually favor companies that may show constant use of a model in commerce.
Nonetheless, for now, McCreary has scored an higher hand, and the best to maintain Taylor Kia of Lima in authorized limbo.
What customers can be taught from McCreary’s revenge
-
Test the paperwork: Whether or not you’re shopping for a automobile, signing a lease, or beginning a enterprise, at all times know precisely what you’re agreeing to. Arbitration clauses can restrict your authorized choices.
-
Public data are public for a cause: State enterprise filings are simple to verify on-line. McCreary’s discovery got here merely from doing her homework.
-
Status issues: For companies, letting registrations lapse can open the door to pricey and embarrassing disputes.
For McCreary, the battle isn’t over, however she’s already proved that typically, the pen actually is mightier than the tow truck.
What to learn subsequent
Keep within the know. Be part of 200,000+ readers and get the very best of Moneywise despatched straight to your inbox each week at no cost. Subscribe now.
This text offers info solely and shouldn’t be construed as recommendation. It’s supplied with out guarantee of any type.
