An uncommonly credible Netflix actioner a few staff of immortal mercenaries who promote their abilities to the very best bidder, Gina Prince-Bythewood’s “The Outdated Guard” was an oasis within the desert when it dropped on Netflix on the top of the pandemic, however I’d be mendacity if I mentioned that it’s actually caught with me over the past 5 years. And but, there’s one element of its story that I haven’t been capable of shake — a personality destiny so grim that it made residing perpetually look like a destiny worse than demise.
In case you’ve seen the film (or learn the graphic novel sequence on which it’s based mostly), what I’m speaking about: An everlasting warrior named Quỳnh (Van Veronica Ngo) is sealed inside an iron maiden throughout a sixteenth century witch trial and solid into the underside of the ocean, the place she’s doomed to drown, gasp again to life, after which drown once more till the tip of time. Not enjoyable!
Be that as it could, Quỳnh didn’t appear too pleased when she inexplicably reappeared on the floor on the finish of the movie. The look on her face was much less “I’m so relieved to have air in my lungs for the primary time in additional than 500 years,” and extra “It’s too dangerous that my mates are perpetually, as a result of I actually wish to homicide them for letting me choke in hell for half a millennium.”
What we already know, and what Quỳnh is conflicted to study in the direction of the start of “The Outdated Guard 2,” is that destiny will give her the prospect for revenge, as her ride-and-not-die bestie Andromache (Charlize Theron) someway misplaced her powers throughout the course of the earlier film. And so the stage would look like set for a enjoyable — and emotionally fraught — grudge match of a sequel about two several-thousand-year-olds who combat over one of the simplest ways to spend the remainder of their all of the sudden finite time collectively.
Alas, neither of those ladies can think about simply how finite that point might be. For one factor, the oldest immortal of all of them (Uma Thurman as Discord) has returned with a plan to purge the Earth of her personal variety. For an additional, “The Outdated Guard 2” is frustratingly — if additionally pointedly — rushed for a film about individuals who’ve been alive for eons, and it by no means offers any of its characters the prospect to meaningfully hash out how the bonds of friendship may pull tighter as they get twisted over the course of some hundred many years.
What does it entail to harm somebody who lives perpetually? How deep can a wound fester when time fails to heal it? Had been Andy and Quỳnh in love, or is the Hays Code-level homoeroticism between them meant to mirror a relationship too huge to be outlined by mortal parameters? A few of these matters are nominally addressed by aggrieved wire-fu and/or an elaborate shootout close to the core of a nuclear energy plant, and “The Outdated Guard 2” — which hits the bottom operating, and takes palpably goofy pleasure in being unburdened from the table-setting that sucked the enjoyable out of the primary one — excels within the uncommon moments when its motion stems from the loaded query of what its characters are actually preventing for.
To a good higher diploma than its predecessor, nevertheless, this sequel is simply too busy satisfying the fundamental circumstances of its style to do something memorable with them. Worse: the gallingly incomplete nature of its story — which ends on Netflix’s largest cliffhanger since “Squid Sport 2,” however with out the good thing about a 3rd chapter within the can — leaves the film with a putrid aftertaste, not solely as a result of it’s so unsatisfying, but in addition as a result of it affirms the ethical of Greg Rucka’s script within the worst attainable method. Andy tells us that point is just as significant as you make it. In that sense, it’s laborious to not really feel just like the 104 minutes it takes to observe “The Outdated Guard 2” are extra of a waste than they’re value.
Anybody nonetheless endeared to those characters from Prince-Bythewood’s installment will most likely benefit from the probability to meet up with them, nevertheless transient it is perhaps. Helming her first film since 2011’s “Yelling to the Sky,” substitute director Victoria Mahoney seizes on the enjoyable of watching Andy’s crew run towards hazard with no care on this planet, and this sequel’s explosive opening sequence — a raid on an arms seller’s mansion in Croatia — is made 1,000,000 occasions extra pleasurable by the satan could care angle that immortals like Nicky (Luca Marinelli, recent off his silent however elegant efficiency in “Demise Stranding 2”) and Joe (Marwan Kenzari) convey to the James Bond-coded automobile chase that caps issues off.
Nile Freeman (KiKi Layne) was a brand new recruit the final time round, however she’s already outgrown any worry of demise, a lot to the identical extent that the newly mortal Andy has but to develop one. Chiwetel Ejiofor’s CIA liaison additionally returns as an viewers surrogate of kinds (somebody must gawp at all the carnage), and although he doesn’t get a ton to do, no film has ever been made worse by having extra Chiwetel Ejiofor in it. And what of Matthias Schoenaerts’ Booker, who was exiled for betraying the Outdated Guard as a part of a bid to treatment his eternality? Effectively, he’s again too, if solely so Quỳnh can use him to search out Andy.
Whereas his scenes with the group are a number of the film’s finest for the way they weigh a single misstep in opposition to a number of millennia of solidarity, there are different traces of nuance within the early going of this story. Nonetheless one of many nice undersung motion stars of the twenty first century, Theron may delegate most of her efficiency in these motion pictures to her jet-black wig, however she convincingly sells the concept that Andy is having fun with her newfound mortality and all that it entails — the hangovers are brutal, however getting drunk is much more enjoyable. The double-edged sword of her reunion with Quỳnh is sharpened by the looming specter of demise, and Mahoney tees it up with a intelligent (and seemingly in-camera) shot that finds Andy strolling by the centuries so as to meet up with the lady who as soon as walked alongside her.
However because the film begins to bullshit its method by the whys and hows of residing perpetually, the process of all of it begins to distract from the feelings at hand, and Discord isn’t remotely fascinating sufficient as a villain to justify all the legwork required to make sense of her plot. Henry Golding performs a bookkeeper whose sole objective is to arrange the lore, however Discord’s risk all the time feels extra contrived than inevitable.
Thurman glowers with the perfect of them, however a furtive plan and some laborious stares isn’t sufficient to assist a personality who’s supposedly been miffed at we mortals ever since she watched Jesus get crucified earlier than her eyes. Does she wish to purge us off the planet, as hijacking a nuclear energy plant may counsel, or is she extra involved together with her personal struggling? “The Outdated Guard 2” tells us the reply, however forces us to attend till the following film, if there even is a subsequent film, to provide a shit about how she obtained there, or what it may imply for Andy’s ever-complicating relationship with Quỳnh.
And there’s treasured little pleasure to be present in that deferral, because the climactic combat — by which Beatrix Kiddo lastly will get to flex her abilities — is an under-lit CGI blah-fest that epitomizes how keen this franchise is to sacrifice its everlasting characters on the altar of hyper-ephemeral streaming dross. That non-finale is very disappointing on the finish of a film that makes an effort, not less than throughout its first half, to run with its premise. The motion could be uneven, and the camerawork grows more and more centered on compensating for little cheats within the movie’s stunt work, however Mahoney by no means misses an opportunity to crush a pair of legs that may develop proper again, or to smash somebody by a window with none concern for what may occur in the event that they catch a shard of glass of their neck.
Watching Joe smush his disembodied thumb again onto his hand with an ideal “thumbs up,” it’s laborious to not want that his franchise may magically pull itself collectively in the identical method. Alas, those that beloved “The Outdated Guard” are going to be those most aggravated by the choice to go away its sequel severed in half. Whether or not it’s the last word aim of her plan or only a byproduct of what she’s actually after, Discord is pleased for folks to undergo; a method or one other, she’s about to get her want.
Grade: C
“The Outdated Guard 2” is now out there to stream on Netflix.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the perfect new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.
