Few modern movies about unresolved childhood abuse — which is at all times unresolved, ultimately, anyway — lower as narrowly near the bone as Elliot Tuttle’s two-hander masked as provocation, “Blue Movie.”
Rejected by mainstream movie festivals earlier than it premiered in Edinburgh this summer season and NewFest in New York in October, this taboo-busting research of a masculine camboy confronted by the pedophile trainer who a few years in the past desired him holds again little and gives even much less that’s palatable to swallow. Its limitations as a stagelike piece apart, the film wrings emotional complexity from a fraught, ever-shifting dialogue between a convicted little one abuser and the coed, now a late twenties intercourse employee, he spared.
“Blue Movie,” which takes place fully in a rented Hancock Park Airbnb in Los Angeles with solely two actors, dares to go locations I’ve not seen an American film journey to shortly. There was an Israeli film known as “Princess” at Sundance in 2014, directed by Tali Shalom Ezer, which freaked lots of people out. It was a couple of 12-year-old lady’s “shut relationship” along with her mom’s boyfriend. There was the 2011 Austrian film “Michael,” directed by Michael Haneke protégé Markus Schleinzer, about an insurance coverage salesman sexually abusing the 10-year-old boy locked up in his basement. These have been surprising. Neither have been American.
Tuttle, an American filmmaker himself who obtained help on the mission from Mark Duplass of all doable collaborators, is prepared to take you to those self same darkish locations, ones that remind you of European administrators who wish to shake you with their frank psychosexual provocations. It’s spectacular the place Tuttle, this second-time function filmmaker, goes together with his surprisingly humanistic and empathetic strategy to materials about abuse. One the place a pedophile trainer’s sexual fantasy about his former pupil’s expertise present efficiency emerges as oddly wistful.
“Blue Movie” stars rising actor Kieron Moore as dom camboy Aaron Eagle (whose actual title is Alex McConnell) reverse Reed Birney as his estranged center faculty trainer, who reconnect over one evening crammed with conversations about need, disgrace, and guilt. I’m not stunned festivals, allegedly akin to Sundance and SXSW, regarded away from it. Mainstream audiences will likely be alienated by this unapologetic exploration of quote-unquote aberrant sexuality, however these in search of a problem within the vein of ‘90s movies from Todd Solondz or Gregg Araki will really feel seen in Tuttle’s exploration of how abuse warps reminiscence, and reminiscence warps accounts of abuse.
In asking you to really feel sorry for a pedophile whereas making a homosexual man his scene associate, “Blue Movie” dances on the difficult line from early abuse to later-in-life sexual habits. When the film begins, we see Aaron (Moore), sweaty and bushy in white briefs and tattooed top-to-toe, placing on a stay stream for his submissive followers. One in all his nameless followers gives $50,000 for an in-person meet-and-greet. Financially determined, he agrees to spend the evening with the consumer, who greets him sheathed in a balaclava with the promise of much more cash and maybe pizza if Aaron is prepared to open up about himself.
That consumer, it seems, is Mr. Grant, aka Hank, Aaron’s long-ago trainer, and one who took a particular curiosity in Aaron as a baby. A while whereas Aaron was in class, Hank was intercepted sexually assaulting a baby on campus, was fired from his job, and obtained a jail sentence. With the masks off and Aaron stripped down but once more, their partitions begin to come down. Hank, he reveals, has now turned to faith as an atonement for his personal torment, however his seek for which means has not been with out different makes an attempt at or contemplations of assaulting children, as he tells Aaron.
Tuttle’s script and digital camera move no judgment on the characters, like when Aaron shares a bone-chilling story of childhood abuse whereas bare in a bath which will or might not be true, or when Hank additionally gives a sickening recounting of molestation he endured by the hands of a relative. The actors are as sport as any you would think about, working from a script imaginable lots of people stated “hell no” to.
Birney, 71, and finest identified for work in tv and theater (“The People”), invitations you to really feel all his harm, at the same time as his world is a morally disturbed one we’re made to stay inside for the film’s operating time. As Aaron, Moore, in the meantime, conceals deep wounds of his personal, whereas additionally excessive on the facility imbalance this example has tipped his manner, the place Hank needs to know if he “nonetheless loves” Aaron. One other wrinkle is that the digital camera definitely needs us to additionally need Moore, who is commonly subsequent to bare, inserting us not less than adjoining to Hank’s gaze.
Hank can also be interested by whether or not he can nonetheless be drawn to grownup whom he as soon as desired as a baby. He shaves Aaron head to toe to make him look extra bodily childlike in one of many movie’s queasier implications. What these two actors tackle is undeniably courageous, even because the film tilts towards turning into suffocating, which is intentional. “Blue Movie” is confined to a single surroundings, in any case.
Cinematographer Ryan Jackson-Healy additionally shot the equally controversy-starting, Birney-led movie “Mass,” in regards to the ramifications of a college capturing for the mother and father affected. The DP is aware of his manner round a decent room with only a few folks, and the visible fantastic thing about this film (certainly, usually cloaked in literal blues as evening turns to daybreak) helps alleviate the agonies on show.
Tuttle properly avoids flashbacks or out-of-this-room context. We’re caught with these two folks and our discomfort with them, despite the fact that we’d additionally really feel tenderness towards them. “Blue Movie” nudges at quite a lot of difficult points, just like the query of whether or not being homosexual within the current day is someway the results of inflictions of the previous. And the parallel to that query is whether or not abuse may beget extra abuse, i.e. make you right into a pedophile or intercourse offender. Hank says he knew who he was as soon as his sexual fantasies in center faculty, about his fellow same-age classmates, remained the identical into maturity. What Tuttle needs to assault right here is that this horrible fork-in-the-road notion that pedophilia and homosexuality stem from the identical root.
Nonetheless, “Blue Movie” does the uncommon work of listening with compassion to a pedophile akin to Hank, and as an viewers, you may both be interested by that or simply let it make you uncomfortable. Hank is laid low with who he’s, as is Aaron, however they aren’t the identical individual, and they didn’t come from the identical place. “Blue Movie” leaves you feeling somewhat bit ailing, and really uneasy about the way you’re alleged to really feel. However when most movies both wouldn’t dare go right here in any respect, or would inform you the right way to really feel in regards to the materials, that’s uncommon and welcome.
Grade: B+
“Blue Movie” premiered on the Edinburgh Movie Pageant and NewFest. It’s presently searching for U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the most effective new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.
