All the pieces it’s essential learn about Pascal Bonitzer’s tightly knotted “Public sale” — a spry and byzantine ethical comedy set within the trenches of the French artwork enterprise — could be inferred from its opening scene. In it, star auctioneer André Masson (Alex Lutz) and his pathological liar of a brand new intern (Louise Chevillotte as Aurore) pay a go to to a blind outdated lady who’s wanting to unload a priceless masterpiece. Does it matter that she’s imply to her maid? It doesn’t. Does it matter that she’s brazenly racist, or that she’s solely promoting the portray in order that her “tramp” of a daughter gained’t stand to inherit it when she dies? Not an opportunity. André will say, do, and/or forgive something as long as it permits him to convey the work to market and make his agency a fortune. What a disgrace that such an beautiful eye for artwork ought to solely be conditioned to search for revenue.
So begins a considerate little tempest of a film that repeatedly circles the questions requested by its first encounter: The place does artwork belong, who deserves to personal it, and the way a lot can we diminish its worth by focusing a lot on its price? These are questions that André — unflappable, lupine, faintly resembling a hollowed-out Baryshnikov — has executed effectively for himself by refusing to consider. Here’s a man who so ruthlessly pursues his purpose, irrespective of how unhealthy it makes him look. “Being hated is nice for the neurons,” he causes to Aurore as a part of a speech in regards to the want for ruthlessness; later, because the intern angrily complains about her boss on the cellphone, André bursts into the room as if wanting to exult in Aurore’s frustration.
However André, who Bonitzer has named after the early surrealist André-Aimé-René Masson, quickly confronts our man with a scenario that — a minimum of on some distant unconscious stage — forces him to re-evaluate his metrics. A misplaced Egon Schiele masterpiece from 1914 is found in the home of a younger chemical employee in a small manufacturing unit metropolis alongside the Swiss border. “Wilted Sunflowers,” thought misplaced throughout World Conflict II after the Nazis looted it, is genuine in additional methods than one: In actual life, this very piece was discovered by an unassuming Frenchman in 2005, who was oblivious to its tainted provenance, and finally offered at public sale for greater than $13 million.
A younger 79-year-old who wrote screenplays for everybody from Jacques Rivette to Paul Verhoeven after developing as a critic at Cahiers du Cinéma (and has all the time loved elevating an eyebrow on the bourgeoise), Bonitzer is much less within the portray itself — about which this movie makes virtually no remark — than he’s in what the portray reveals of the numerous totally different people who find themselves drawn into its orbit. Per French custom, Bonitzer emphasizes manners over moralité, and so “Public sale” makes use of André as extra of a Dantean tour information by the underworld of the artwork enterprise than as a typical hero. Which is to say, this isn’t the story of a grasping, materialistic man who suffers a disaster of conscience whereas making an attempt to pry a priceless treasure away from an uneducated hick who doesn’t know any higher.
That is, to a level, precisely what André wish to do, however “Public sale” complicates its predominant character’s trajectory till it doesn’t resemble an arc a lot as a chaotic bidding battle. Whereas Martin (Arcadi Radeff), the expediently harmless manufacturing unit employee with the “Wilted Sunflowers” on his wall, doesn’t appear tired of his success, everybody else in André’s path has a really mounted concept of who ought to revenue from it. That features Martin’s associates, who see this because the rating of a lifetime, his disarmingly relaxed lawyer (Nora Hamzawi), and the American Jew who claims to symbolize the rightful heirs of Schiele’s treasure. The scenario turns into so messy so quick that André turns to his ex-wife (a playful Léa Drucker as Bertina), of all individuals, for assist; she’s in love with somebody new, but additionally appears to be turned on by the fun of a misplaced Schiele falling into her lap.
As if that weren’t sufficient for this 90-minute movie to suit into its body, Bonitzer takes pains to recommend that Aurore may need her personal agenda (it’s actually arduous to inform along with her), and that André himself is merely a software of the public sale home the place he works. The plot unfolds on the pressing however erratic tempo of a life-altering enterprise deal, as Bonitzer unfussily steers us by a collection of small rooms as individuals scramble to find out the correct factor to do with Schiele’s portray. The extra they argue over the worth of “Wilted Sunflowers,” the extra we sense that they’re being compelled to cope with the worth of the argument they’re making. Their very own price, their very own function, their very own provenance.
Reasonably than key into any specific facet of what meaning, the fast-moving “Public sale” — usually sober, however by no means various levels faraway from tipping right into a cheeky satire of its characters’ self-importance — creates an elaborate matrix of buried secrets and techniques, invented pasts, and plain histories. Sophisticated sufficient to lose an off-the-cuff viewer however by no means so convoluted that André and co. are sublimated into the system round them (which might have been deadly for a movie so attuned to the connection between private curiosity and collective notion), Bonitzer’s plot spins ahead on the pace of an auctioneer’s mouth till uncooked suspense turns into appropriately inextricable from meaningless gibberish.
It’s all good enjoyable, however the film’s core reality is decidedly unsmiling: In case you comply with play the sport, you need to abide by its guidelines. In case you let the market determine the worth of a ratty outdated canvas, you need to settle for the collective verdict of a factor’s perceived worth. Everybody has a job to play. Solely Martin — forged as a Dickensian wretch by Bonitzer’s legion of myopic elites, however all the time quietly performing in opposition to sort — reserves the precise to find out his personal price.
Grade: B
“Public sale” is now enjoying in theaters.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the most effective new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.
