Editor’s Observe: This overview initially ran in the course of the 2025 SXSW Movie and TV Competition. “The Dutchman” opens in choose theaters on Friday, January 2, 2026.
André Holland continues his streak as one of many sharpest dramatic actors working as we speak — and I’m not simply speaking about “Moonlight,” have you ever seen TV’s “The Knick”? — as a New York businessman in marital freefall in Andre Gaines’ “The Dutchman.” Gaines and co-writer Qasim Basir raise Amiri Baraka’s traditional 1964 play out of its midcentury Civil Rights Motion context and transplant the textual content to present-day Manhattan, the place Clay (Holland) goes mad over his spouse Kaya’s (Zazie Beetz) current admission of an infidelity.
So launches a darkish evening of the soul via the town that echoes “Eyes Broad Shut” — by which mysterious ladies additionally tempt a spiraling Tom Cruise over a night after Nicole Kidman confesses to extramarital ideas — and even “After Hours” with its magical realism and deus-ex-machina moments of utter (and intentional) absurdity. However Clay’s psychosexual and private freefall doesn’t land him at a Lengthy Island orgy for the tremendous wealthy. As a substitute, this successful-on-paper Black businessman is taunted by the amorous, sexually unctuous Lula (Kate Mara), a white stranger who is aware of manner too many intimate particulars about him. Like the truth that he’s attempting to develop a beard, and extra of the kind of ideas reserved for an inner working monologue, the stuff you assume alone at nighttime, mendacity in mattress awake at evening.
“The Dutchman” journeys up on a couple of too many self-aware reflexes, corresponding to how Clay’s therapist, Dr. Amiri (Stephen McKinley Henderson), fingers him a replica of Baraka’s play on which this film relies as a kind of self-help textual content. However Holland’s arresting and understated efficiency as an more and more helpless man overwhelmed by a presumably imaginary lady’s sexual wiles — and by his personal place within the universe as a Black man on a company, white-laid monitor to no place fulfilling — makes “The Dutchman” a hypnotic watch.
Baraka wrote the play “Dutchman” the 12 months earlier than Malcolm X was killed in 1965, and it was made right into a controversial sharp shock of a British indie starring Shirley Knight and Al Freeman Jr. two years after the civil rights chief’s demise. The unique textual content centered on a white lady, additionally named Lula, who confronts and mocks a Black man in a New York Metropolis subway automobile. There, Clay was a logo of Black male id in shifting occasions and of how white ladies degrade and debase Black males in turning them into unique sexual objects.
Gaines directs his first narrative function after documentaries on baseball icon Jackie Robinson, Olympic athlete Jesse Owens, and comic Dick Gregory, right here increasing Baraka’s two-scene two-hander (which premiered in Greenwich Village) to incorporate the opposite individuals exerting strain onto Clay’s orbit. “The Dutchman” the film begins throughout a tense couple’s counseling session, with Kaya laying out her unrest to Dr. Amiri, cinematographer Frank G. DeMarco (“All Is Misplaced”) emphasizing the emotional gulf of an area between her and Clay.
Clay has been repeatedly instructed by buddies, together with rising politico Warren (Aldis Hodge), that he may as effectively step exterior the wedding, too, as Kaya has. However Clay is just too uncomfortable in his personal pores and skin — in all senses — and unsure of his cracking masculinity to even take into account the impulse or act on it confidently. And if ever you wanted to listen to the argument that heterosexual {couples} ought to institute open marriages the way in which homosexual individuals so comfortably do — and have made all however a relationship customary at this level — “The Dutchman” makes that case. Guys, this is able to simply resolve loads of your issues upfront.
So it’s no shock that Clay is tentative, nervous, and even a bit humiliated when Lula sidles as much as him on a subway automobile, Mara styled in a strappy bodycon gown and raven-red hair to overstate her mirage-like entrance into his life. Did Clay dream this white lady up, or is that this dour manic pixie dream lady solely a literary machine, the film itself dreaming, whose attention-getting silhouette can be meant to name consideration to her personal artifice as a author’s creation? “The Dutchman” dances with such meta, don’t-forget-this-is-a-movie self-consciousness all through, as Clay’s New York setting subtly morphs round him. It’s not completely defined why or developed additional, extra ominous mood-setting to externalize Clay’s splintering psyche. Setting an extended stretch on the subway, too, conjures emotions across the repeat killings of Black males on MTA automobiles. In different phrases, for somebody like Clay, it’s already a harmful setting fraught with the potential for violence — emotional and bodily.
Lula’s (is that basically her title?) sexual rapaciousness takes maintain once they wind up again at her condominium, Clay’s bodily arousal plain and even seen, she claims. She says she’s so certain she felt his erection that she might draw a map of it. Lula desires to be thrown round onto the mattress, a gesture Clay has a nervous feeling about — even within the privateness of a studio condominium, the concept of a Black man bodily taking cost of a white lady on this manner comes with its personal apparent baggage.
Gaines works to free the stagebound supply materials by having Lula comply with (i.e. principally stalk) Clay into the evening, and to a celebration celebrating Warren, the place Kaya is in attendance and feeling vindictive. Confrontations ensue as Clay’s darkish evening of the soul lastly places his marriage on trial, and Lula’s true intentions start to disclose themselves. However “The Dutchman” the film doesn’t fairly transcend the sensation of getting been a play, regardless of some supernatural thrives by which Clay drifts right into a dream state seemingly to confront different variations of himself. Nonetheless, as with every nice theater, the performances listed below are excellent, with Holland telegraphing Clay’s years of insecurity into the confines of a one-night-only film that opens a window onto a Black id disaster, solely to close it down on us as we peer over the sill.
Grade: B
“The Dutchman” premiered on the 2025 SXSW Movie & TV Competition. Rogue Photos and Inaugural Leisure launch the movie January 2.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the most effective evaluations, streaming picks, and provides some new musings, all solely obtainable to subscribers.
