It’s one of many nice ironies that the individuals within the U.S. who stand against trans rights typically stand in kneejerk opposition to Iran and something associated to it. One might think about nice affinity between the fundamentalist non secular conservatives of the U.S. and Islamic fundamentalism, if it weren’t for that pesky difficulty of racism and the reactive Islamophobia that comes with it.
Which is why it’s such a stirring jolt to observe Farnoosh Samadi‘s “Between Goals and Hope,” probably the greatest movies a couple of trans romance in a while… that additionally occurs to be from Iran. Gender-affirming surgical procedures can be found in Iran, although with tight restrictions involving parental consent, even for these in search of the surgical procedure at college age. The truth that it’s established upfront in Samadi’s movie that such a process is offered in Iran in any respect ought to dispel some misconceptions about life within the nation (although anti-trans forces within the U.S. and Europe have additionally peddled misinformation suggesting that the Iranian regime forces cisgender homosexuals to obtain the surgical procedure as a manner of “curing” them of their homosexuality).
There’s a lot in the way in which of misconceptions which might be dispelled right here that that one might see a Western viewer being taken out of Samadi’s narrative by the sheer revelatory nature of all of it — besides that Samadi has created such a gripping movie, one among such deep empathy and narrative immersion, it’s laborious to think about anybody’s thoughts would wander watching “Between Goals and Hope.” At the least past a slack first act.
Azad (performed by the cisgender feminine actress Fereshteh Hosseini) is a trans male who’s but to obtain gender-affirming surgical procedure. There’s a authorized course of for making use of for one in Iran, and he’s fulfilled all the necessities besides one: He must get his father’s signature on a kind giving his permission. What follows for the 106 minutes is a flurry of conflicting pronouns as Azad is routinely misgendered by these round him, aside from his girlfriend, Nora (Sadaf Asgari).
Nevertheless it turns into obvious shortly what a tricky life Azad has had: He grew up in a small rural village, the place conventional attitudes have made trans acceptance virtually inconceivable — the very existence of trans individuals there may be virtually extraordinary. When he went to school in Tehran, he discovered an accepting circle of mates, and fell in love with Nora. It’s been years now since he’s seen his household. They’ve all however accused her of inflicting the demise of her grandmother over the stress attributable to her “being a woman who needs to develop into a boy.”
Hosseini and Asgari flip in deeply felt, naturalistic performances. They don’t seem to be strolling points or symbols handed off as characters simply to make a degree. They’re characters, and richly drawn. The primary 40 minutes of “Between Goals and Hope” take the tone of a hangout film as we get to know them. We meet their mates and see them placed on somewhat dramatic studying from “Romeo & Juliet” by which Azad proposes to Nora. He needs to marry her. However in fact, in Iran, that may’t occur till his surgical procedure is behind him. The primary third of the film drags only a bit as its characters are in a form of limbo, questioning find out how to proceed: They want Azad’s father’s signature, and but they know he won’t ever give it. What to do?
As soon as Azad decides to drive to his household farm and try to get his father’s signature anyway, the story actually kicks in — and is so compelling it largely excuses the quasi-aimlessness of the primary act. Azad’s father is unmoved, and his older brother is outright hostile and threatening violence. They should depart her fast, the scene made all of the extra relentless by the digicam whip-panning between Azad and her father throughout their argument as a substitute of shot-reverse-shot chopping. However fortunately, Azad reconnects along with his youthful brother, who nonetheless lives in a mindset of pure love and compassion earlier than the adolescent and grownup impulses of disgrace and “what is going to individuals say?” can infect him.
Azad decides to return to his household dwelling that night time. This time with out Nora. And fateful circumstances ensue… off-camera. Azad doesn’t come again. And Nora is anxious sick. The subsequent morning, she goes to the household farm and ask in the event that they know the place Azad is. The solutions Nora will get again from Azad’s father and brother are dismissive, curt, and even threatening. This doesn’t look good. And the menace is underscored by Hamadi staging most of those tense scenes in lengthy takes. She doesn’t give us the protected haven of modifying.
However the precise contours of what occurred depart some twists and turns forward, which we received’t spoil right here. The strain ratchets as much as the purpose that when you’re considering “the place is that this going?” within the first 40 minutes, it turns into “I can barely stand the suspense” within the final act. It’s extremely compelling, and made all of the extra immersive by the inky pure lighting of a key scene on the finish. “Between Goals and Hope” in the end ends with probably the most memorable ultimate pictures in a while. In each manner, it is a big step up for Hamadi from her debut characteristic, 2020’s “180-Diploma Rule.” With this second movie, she’s arrived as a significant filmmaker.
For Western viewers, it’ll hopefully have the added dimension of producing extra empathy for Iranians and dwelling in that nation. There may be nothing right here that would disgrace Iran or its authorities. The city vs. rural, liberal vs. conservative dynamic we see unfold in “Between Goals and Hope” is way the identical as within the U.S. It is a movie that ought to make us all extra delicate, extra attuned, extra questioning of our biases. The truth that it’s such a riveting expertise makes it all of the extra highly effective in that regard.
Grade: A-
“Between Goals and Hope” premiered on the 2025 Toronto Worldwide Movie Competition. It’s at the moment in search of U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up one of the best new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.
