In November 2024 I used to be interviewed for a fabulous NPR podcast referred to as Dwelling On Earth about my newest standard science ebook, Underneath Alien Skies. Whereas prepping for the present, one of many producers requested me a query that was so deceptively easy, so splendidly succinct, and got here from such an odd route that I used to be instantly enamored with it.
Are you able to drink Saturn’s rings?
After pausing for a second to savor the query, I replied with one in all my favourite responses as a scientist and science communicator: “I don’t know. However I’ll attempt to discover out.”
On supporting science journalism
For those who’re having fun with this text, think about supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By buying a subscription you might be serving to to make sure the way forward for impactful tales in regards to the discoveries and concepts shaping our world at this time.
So I did. And to my delight, the nuanced reply I discovered is one other private favourite: Sure! However no. Kinda. It relies upon.
I really like this type of reply as a result of it arises when the science behind a seemingly straightforward query may be very a lot not so easy.
So please seize a frosty glass of (regionally sourced) ice water, sit again and let me clarify.
Saturn’s rings had been possible first seen by Galileo in 1610. His telescope was pretty low-quality in contrast with fashionable tools. And thru its optics, all he may see had been a pair of blobs, one on either side of the planet’s seen face; he referred to them as Saturn’s “ears.”
It wasn’t till a number of a long time later that astronomers realized these “ears” had been really a planet-encircling ring. A lot was nonetheless unclear, however one factor was sure: the ring couldn’t be strong. The velocity at which an object orbits a planet depends upon its distance from that world, and Saturn’s ring was so huge that the interior edge would orbit far more quickly than its periphery, which might shear something strong aside.
Astronomers got here up with quite a lot of totally different concepts for the construction, together with a sequence of strong ringlets or perhaps a liquid. It wasn’t till the mid-1800s that the nice Scottish physicist James Clerk Maxwell proved none of those could be secure and as a substitute proposed what we now know to be true: the construction round Saturn was product of numerous small particles, which had been far too tiny to be seen individually from Earth.
Additional, these small objects type not only one ring however a number of, and these main rings are designated by letters so as of their discovery. The A hoop is the outermost shiny ring. Simply inside to it’s the shiny and broad B ring, which incorporates many of the whole ring system’s mass. Inside to that’s the darker C ring, which leads all the way down to the faint D ring that extends nearly to the higher ambiance of Saturn itself. In whole these rings stretch throughout almost 275,000 kilometers—two thirds of the Earth-moon distance! Regardless of their immense sprawl, the rings are nearly impossibly flat, in lots of locations nearly 10 meters thick. Seen precisely edge-on, they appear like a slim line reducing throughout the planet.
Saturn’s rings had been named alphabetically within the order they had been found, as proven on this animation. The slim F ring marks the outer boundary of the primary ring system.
NASA/JPL-Caltech/House Science Institute
However what are they product of? Observations over the centuries have revealed that the primary constituent of the rings is startlingly easy: water ice! Good ol’ frozen H2O is extraordinarily frequent within the outer photo voltaic system and makes up most of many moons and different small our bodies there.
The truth is, in situ observations carried out by the Cassini spacecraft—which orbited Saturn for greater than a dozen years—confirmed that in some locations the rings had been made of just about completely pure water ice. Even higher, many of the ring bits are a number of centimeters throughout or smaller—the scale of ice cubes, so that they’re already conveniently packaged.
Sounds nice! All it is advisable to do then is scoop up some chunks, heat them—a lot (the common temperature of the rings is about –190 levels Celsius)—and have your self a pleasant, refreshing sip.
However not so quick. That is the place it will get extra difficult. The spectra of the rings additionally present that they aren’t product of completely pure ice. There’s different materials within the rings, and despite the fact that we’re usually speaking about contamination of lower than 1 % by mass, it’s not clear what these items is. Scientists’ greatest guess is that it comes from the impacts of micrometeorites, tiny particles whizzing across the outer photo voltaic system. This materials is due to this fact possible composed of silicates (that’s, rocks) or considerable metals, specifically iron.
Neither of those will hurt you, though the U.S. Environmental Safety Company recommends not more than 0.3 milligram of iron per liter of potable water (to keep away from a metallic style). You’d higher run a magnet over your ring water earlier than you drink it—and it is best to in all probability filter out any silicate sediments whilst you’re at it.
Alternatively, the rings’ spectra counsel the presence of some unknown carbon-based contaminants as nicely. One possible candidate could be complicated natural molecules referred to as polycyclic fragrant compounds, or PAHs, that are comparatively prevalent in house; many huge stars blow out PAH-laced winds as they die. One molecule that’s generally current in PAHs is cyanonaphthalene, which is taken into account carcinogenic. (It’s unclear, although, how a lot publicity poses dangers to people—or, for that matter, whether or not this particular molecule really exists within the rings.)
It’s greatest to be cautious and keep away from these potential contaminants by choosing your rings rigorously. The abundance of water ice is highest within the outer A and center B rings, for instance, whereas the C and D rings look like essentially the most contaminated. So, typically talking, it’d in all probability be higher to go for ice from A or B whereas skipping C and D fully.
There may be different ices within the rings, too, together with frozen methane and carbon dioxide. Methane ought to bubble out when the ice is liquefied, and naturally CO2 is what makes carbonated drinks fizzy. That may really add a enjoyable kick to consuming from the rings!
There are different rings, too, outdoors the foremost ones we’ve already talked about. For instance, Saturn’s icy moon Enceladus boasts dozens of geysers that blast liquid water from its inside out into house. This materials varieties a faint, fuzzy ring (the E ring) that, once more, is generally water ice but in addition incorporates small quantities of silicates—and noxious ammonia—so I wouldn’t suggest it.
Nonetheless, all in all, it seems like—if rigorously curated and cleaned—Saturn’s rings are certainly drinkable!
How a lot water is there within the rings, then? The entire mass of the rings is about 1.5 × 1019 kilograms, which, correcting for the density of ice and the elimination of contaminants, ought to yield about 10 quintillion liters of water—sufficient to maintain each human on Earth nicely hydrated for greater than one million years.
Finally, if and when people begin to ply the interplanetary space-lanes, they’ll want extraterrestrial sources of water as a result of lifting it from Earth is tough and costly. Saturn’s rings would possibly sometime turn out to be a well-liked relaxation cease. And, oh my, what a view guests would have as they crammed up!
My due to my buddy and outer photo voltaic system big planet astronomer Heidi Hammel for her assist with this text and to El Wilson for asking me this terrific query!
