Editor’s Be aware: This evaluate was initially printed in the course of the 2024 Toronto Movie Pageant. Republic Footage releases “Shell” in choose theaters Friday, October 3.
Some films undergo due to dangerous timing. “Shell” wouldn’t be an excellent film underneath any circumstances, nevertheless it fares particularly poorly in opposition to Coralie Fargeat’s “The Substance,” a greater and extra outrageous movie that offers in very comparable material. “Outrageous” is what director Max Minghella goes for right here. And when it accepts its future as a ‘50s-style rubber-suit sci-fi monster film, “Shell” does have camp worth to it. Even then, it nonetheless doesn’t decide to the bit arduous sufficient to make it profitable.
There are some humorous moments in “Shell” — each intentional and unintentional — and a few eye-catching pictures. The primary dwelling creature to look on display screen is a fluffy lap canine smeared with blood, which mixes the 2; it trots down a darkish hallway in an ‘80s-style mansion, its little legs shifting as quick as they will. The digicam follows the canine right into a retro tiled lavatory, the place Elizabeth Berkley is sitting in a shell-pink bathtub sporting an identical silk gown slicing grotesque black bumps off of her leg. She’s freaking out. The bathtub is slippery with blood. She passes out and drops the knife, and the canine begins licking it clear.
It’s a promising chilly open, one which leads into an uneasy mix of tried pathos and drained entertainment-industry satire as Samantha (Elisabeth Moss) goes out for what she thinks is a gathering with the director of one of many downbeat indie films Moss typically stars in in actual life. It seems to be an open audition, and Samantha loses the function — a divorced single mom of two — to “it” woman Chloe Benson (Kaia Gerber). Chloe is barely sufficiently old to drink, not to mention have two children, however she’s scorching and common on social media so there you go. The expertise leads Samantha’s reps (one in every of whom is performed by Ziwe, completely solid) to counsel, their voices thick with smarmy faux-concern, that she go relaxation on the Shell clinic for some time.
CEO Zoe Shannon (Kate Hudson) is the face of Shell, an organization whose companies mix parts of “Loss of life Turns into Her” and “The Lobster.” In a spa-like ambiance, individuals like Samantha can stave off their concern of irrelevance by present process an outpatient process the place their DNA is fused with the DNA of a lobster, or one thing, leading to a youthful, stronger, taller model of themselves with clear pores and skin and vibrant eyes. Loads is defined, however none of it sticks. The one issues that land are the slicing jokes, which, once more, are nothing new — do you know Los Angeles is a shallow and insincere place? — however get some chuckles within the second.
The satire right here is clumsy, gesturing at comparable factors already made in higher films. There’s a rule in comedy that if it’s important to clarify a joke, it’s not an excellent joke, and an identical kind of ambiguity is at play right here. It’s not all the time clear if, say, a montage set to “Walkin’ on Sunshine” after her Shell therapy improves Samantha’s life is a tongue-in-cheek parody of tacky ‘80s films, or if it’s simply plain tacky itself. This all ties into the camp issue, which might even be used to clarify away hacky particulars like Samantha’s cat as a stand-in for her spinsterhood. Hypothetically.
“Shell” additionally fancies itself physique horror, however once more it doesn’t commit arduous sufficient to really excel in that space. Samantha barfs up some black bile, and Zoe’s sycophants eat her pores and skin at a cocktail party in a bit that briefly frames her as a Christ determine however doesn’t go anyplace. Then there are the bumps that pop up when the process “goes mistaken,” that are referred to within the movie as “scales” however are extra just like the sort of lumpy mole that will immediate a go to to the dermatologist. A complete rash of them is fairly gross, however not as gross because it must be. The place’s the goop?
Mysterious pink liquids are injected into keen topics from unlabeled vials on the Shell clinic, once more shades of “The Substance.” Even the floor aesthetics of the movies are comparable: Each have an eye fixed for ‘80s-inspired fashions and structure, which manifests right here within the type of silver lamé and curved strains. The heightened actuality of this movie will not be as properly constructed, nonetheless, and with a lot much less intentionality: The self-driving vehicles that seem within the background all through the movie,for instance, serve no specific objective besides to shore up its sci-fi credentials.
Everybody in “Shell” lives on this actuality aside from schlumpy everywoman Moss, who appears like she’s a couple of half-step off from everybody else. That’s not a failure on the a part of the actor, who has confirmed herself greater than succesful many instances over. It’s indicative of the general clumsiness of the challenge, whose lack of consistency is current even in little particulars like that incontrovertible fact that a few of the magazines within the movie are actual (Samantha is profiled in “Vainness Truthful”) and others aren’t (ditto for Zoe in “Individuals”).
Hudson, in the meantime, does perceive the tone Minghella is aiming for right here, or is probably setting it herself. Her motivations for hanging up a friendship with Samantha are inscrutable and predatory, and she or he performs the chilly villainess with relish as she struts round in fabulous robes and purrs out pseudo-scientific bullshit. (There’s additionally the potential for a lesbian subtext to her relationship with Moss, however that is sadly underdeveloped.) Her perfection is meant to make her hateable, and Moss’ imperfection is equally meant to border her as relatable. However pulling off that dynamic in a film that additionally has human-sized crustaceans in it’s a challenge for a extra expert filmmaker than this one.
Grade: C
“Shell” premiered on the 2024 Toronto Worldwide Movie Pageant. Republic Footage releases the movie Friday, October 3, 2025.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up the perfect critiques, streaming picks, and affords some new musings, all solely accessible to subscribers.
