A serious star for almost all of his grownup life, Jay Kelly has so totally subsumed himself into his basic display persona — smirking, debonair, heroic — that he now not appears to know who he’s off set. Extra troublingly, the world-famous actor has come to love it that manner. As Sylvia Plath as soon as wrote: “It’s a hell of a duty to be your self. It’s a lot simpler to be any individual else or no person in any respect.”
That quote serves as an nearly oppressively becoming epigraph for the misty-eyed Netflix film that Noah Baumbach has made about one of many final true Hollywood stars — or two of them, I ought to say, as Jay Kelly is so clear a stand-in for the actor who performs him that he and George Clooney share the identical physique of labor. (No grievance right here: “Humorous Folks” is considered one of my favourite genres). Plath’s phrases assist to border “Jay Kelly” because the story of a dashing sexagenerian who’s identified by everybody and nobody in equal measure, however Baumbach’s uncharacteristically valuable screenplay, co-written with thee Emily Mortimer, has little bother articulating that dilemma by itself phrases.
One catchy line that claws on the identical thought: “All my recollections are motion pictures.” Jay delivers it in direction of the beginning of the movie, so quickly after he’s wrapped manufacturing on a brand new crime image — “8 Males from Now,” which ends with the actor dying for the umpteenth time — that he would possibly as effectively nonetheless be studying from a script. There’s an instantly perceptible twinge of remorse in Clooney’s voice, just like the form of capturing ache that may’t imply something critical as long as you select to disregard it, however the actual wound of that double-bladed dialogue gained’t be felt till a lot later.
The issue for Jay isn’t that his motion pictures are recollections, and that he’s gone from one half to a different for thus lengthy that he’s forgotten how one can act with out the cameras rolling; that’s a drawback, but additionally one which has at all times managed to unravel itself. No, the issue for Jay is that his recollections are motion pictures: They’re frozen in time, shared by everybody who’s seen them, and virtually not possible to alter as soon as they’ve been cemented within the public creativeness. On set, Jay has the ability to go once more. To do one other take. To get yet another only for security. In life, nevertheless, he has to stay with the alternatives he’s made. And as Jay reaches a sure age and begins being threatened with profession tributes, he abruptly finds himself pressured to observe these decisions again in a veritable supercut of nice success and profound misgiving.
Which is to say that sure, “Jay Kelly” is a bubbly champagne drama that tries to wring a number of tears from the insufferable lightness of being wealthy and well-known, however the truth that it appears like a Lavazza industrial and bemoans the isolation of flying non-public is in the end in service to a extra relatable story in regards to the trade-offs that every one of us are pressured to make on this life — the one-way roads we tackle the lengthy and round journey in direction of turning into ourselves. Baumbach lacks Sofia Coppola’s singular potential to leverage a personality’s wealth for the wanting it reveals of them, however he, Mortimer, and Clooney share a vivid understanding of the resentments that may kind within the area between who we’re and the way we’re seen — and of how stardom can widen that area to the purpose that friendships and households are liable to fall into it unnoticed.
It’s an area that Baumbach explores right here with an unusually light contact. On the one hand, the “Meyerowitz Tales” director has by no means been as allergic to sentimentality as his prickliest work would possibly recommend, and I discover it exhausting to begrudge any of the nice filmmakers for going delicate as they grow old — we must always all be so fortunate to achieve the again half of our lives and really feel as if the world was a kinder, extra loving place than we as soon as thought. Alternatively, watching a director as scabrous as Noah Baumbach make a film as tenderly indrawn as “Jay Kelly” can really feel like watching a ginsu knife get dulled right into a loofah.
Right here, Baumbach compensates for that typically clumsily overdrawn emotionality by rooting his movie in a cragged bedrock of unhappiness — one which provides a serrated edge to the fixed chorus of “I used to be too busy having intercourse with film stars to spend time with my daughters” melancholy. That unhappiness is baked into the story from the beginning, as “Jay Kelly” begins with the dying of a mentor determine named Peter (Jim Broadbent, seen in flashback), who directed Jay’s breakout success 30 years earlier. Peter was desperately heading off irrelevance the final time they spoke, and had begged Jay to assist him get his comeback mission off the bottom. Jay felt the mission was too uncooked and susceptible for his model, and was unmoved by Peter’s enchantment to his filial responsibility. In the long run, Peter did not get the film financed, and Jay can’t assist however suspect that it actually killed him.
That suspicion furrows one thing deep behind Jay’s eyes; it’s a critical wrinkle on the face of somebody whose job requires him to be a dimple-cheeked clean slate always, pliable sufficient to play quite a lot of components however at all times recognizably “himself.” An entire crew of individuals have devoted the very best years of their lives to making sure that Jay by no means has to really feel something worse than delicate discomfort, his candy if self-annihilating supervisor Ron Sukenick (Adam Sandler) chief amongst them, however they don’t decide up on the aftershocks of Peter’s dying till after it’s too late. They don’t know what’s going to occur when Jay is lured to a bar for a post-funeral drink together with his outdated performing faculty pal Timothy (Billy Crudup), who’s aged right into a pediatrician with a critical chip on his shoulder.
The subsequent factor Ron is aware of, Jay has a black eye, he’s pulling out of the large new film he’s as a consequence of begin in a number of days, and he’s loading his complete crew onto a airplane to France as a part of a wildly ill-advised plan to crash his teenage daughter’s European trip and spend some high quality time together with her earlier than she goes to school within the fall. It’s the right setup for a Sturgian misadventure throughout the continent, however “Jay Kelly” — extra frantic than humorous, and more and more trending in direction of wistful revelation — is much less all in favour of pursuing madcap laughs than it’s in exploring the lifetime of the thoughts. And so an in a single day prepare experience that places Jay among the many widespread folks turns into the venue for a head journey down reminiscence lane, full with Trafalmadorian flashbacks that taunt the film star by denying him one other take.
By design, “Jay Kelly” strikes an uneasy stability between shifting ahead and being caught previously. The lengthy and emotionally imprecise flashbacks — which discover Jay revisiting the important audition the place he upstaged Timothy, a set romance he had with considered one of his co-stars, and a newer remedy session that he attended together with his semi-estranged grownup daughter (Riley Keough) — are supposed to act as headwinds for a narrative a couple of man careening uncontrolled, however none of them crackle with Baumbach’s normal wit, and all of them undergo from a barely elevated tone that solely serves the “unreality” of Jay’s life by making each a part of it even tougher to imagine.
That Clooney is simply enjoying a sadder, extra blinkered model of himself — one who by no means discovered an enduring love, nor began a household he was all in favour of protecting — would appear to unravel any problems with verisimilitude, and there are a variety of sequences in “Jay Kelly” the place his real-life fame provides credence to the chaos we’re seeing on-screen (most of them having to do with a starstruck member of the general public). There are additionally a number of moments during which the self-reflexiveness of Clooney’s casting successfully baits us into believing that the Cary Grant of his day is baring his soul for our edification. That he’s waving us backstage and confessing the terrible reality that some a part of ourselves at all times appeared for behind each pink carpet smile and Golden Globes acceptance speech. That he’s not that completely happy. That his life isn’t good. That cash, appears, and an unimpeachable run throughout the six best seasons of any community drama ever made don’t make him higher than us, despite the fact that that third factor objectively does.
The final of these moments is heartstoppingly transcendent, as Baumbach brings the total weight of Clooney’s iconography to bear on Jay’s most non-public misgivings. The issue is that the remainder of them depend on Clooney’s persona to get the job performed, and — in stark distinction to the unsparing honesty of “Humorous Folks” — they aren’t imply sufficient to promote us on the concept Jay might be such a dithering cocker spaniel in his non-public life (there’s a cause why Ron at all times addresses him as “pet,” in addition to the truth that Ron addresses all of his purchasers that manner).
There’s no use in faulting Clooney for his efficiency, as nobody does Clooney higher, and his main man enchantment — in some way wide-eyed and “aw shucks” on the identical time — has seldom been used extra acutely than it’s right here. Alas, his ineffable Clooney-ness additionally has the perverse impact of creating “Jay Kelly” much less convincing on the identical time, at the very least as far as its lead character is being performed by a person who makes all of his foibles that a lot tougher to imagine. I’m positive George Clooney has issues of his personal, however nobody would have a tougher time inhabiting the issues that Corge Glooney is supposed to have on this film. That Jay Kelly’s flaws conflict towards George Clooney’s charms is exactly the purpose, after all — one is just no match for the opposite.
It’s as much as the remainder of the forged to assist degree the enjoying subject, however the one factor “Jay Kelly” does with its touring circus is to winnow them down one after the other as they get bored with Jay’s antics. He’s the overgrown little one who takes them away from their precise kids, blithely detached to the truth that he means extra to them than they do to him in return.
Some staff, like his publicist (Laura Dern), bail on the first signal of actual bother. Others, like Ron, are affected by too nice a sunk-cost fallacy to stop on him now. Sandler wears the shit out of a puffy Polo vest, and it’s enjoyable to see him lead with quiet resignation as an alternative of unchecked rage, however I don’t know if he’s ever starred in a film that’s given him much less to do. Whereas Baumbach makes use of Ron to gesture on the particularly Hollywood issues of blending enterprise with pleasure, and to handle the sheer variety of people who find themselves subsumed into the non-public identification of a single brand-name star (“You’re Jay Kelly,” Ron moans, “however I’m Jay Kelly too”), the character by no means develops past the tender embodiment of all of the issues his boss has forfeited alongside the best way, together with self-awareness, a cohesive household, and a spouse performed by Greta Gerwig.
Getting near different folks was one thing that Jay at all times deliberate to do later, and the prospect of receiving a tribute from a Tuscan movie competition is an unavoidable signal that he’s working out of time. However different folks had been at all times going to be incidental to what actually issues about “Jay Kelly,” a gorgeously bittersweet shortfaller that hits hardest as a cautionary story in regards to the perils of attempting to keep away from oneself in a world that solely permits us to behave like there’s anybody else for us to be. Being a film star simply makes it that a lot simpler to go on the roles you had been born to play.
Grade: B-
“Jay Kelly” premiered on the 2025 Venice Movie Pageant. Netflix will launch it in choose theaters on Friday, November 14, and on Netflix on Friday, December 5.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the very best new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.
