There’s something fairly humorous about how a key factor of the long-awaited fourth season of the Netflix fantasy collection “The Witcher” includes its central character being embodied by what might be generously described as a vaguely comparable doppelgänger who isn’t actually fooling anybody. It doubtless received’t be humorous sufficient to cease followers from crying over the lack of their beloved Henry Cavill, whose charismatic magical warrior Geralt has now been changed by Liam Hemsworth’s lackluster impersonation of him.
Nonetheless, on this sporadic hit-and-miss new season, viewers will need to cling to even the unintentionally enjoyable moments the place they will get them.
At the start, there isn’t a getting across the Hemsworth within the room. Whilst there may be a lot else happening with Season 4’s new journey and break up storylines, and loads of contemporary faces who pop up alongside the way in which, his presence is the one factor that regularly stands proud like a sore thumb.
And the present suffers for it. Although it was at all times a tall order for Hemsworth to step into Cavill’s large footwear because the lead of a longtime ensemble beloved by “the present’s viewers, the brand new Geralt by no means rises to the event. That the season doesn’t do him any favors with a clunky, glorified previously-on reintroduction to the character — exposing how flat he’s compared to the memorable warrior from previous seasons — solely makes the going that a lot more durable.
However there’s causes to not totally write off “The Witcher.” Particularly, nearly all of the remaining forged all slip again into their components with ease in Season 4. The primary trio of Freya Allan’s Ciri, Anya Chalotra’s Yennefer and Joey Batey’s Jaskier, all of whom had the closest relationships with Geralt, stay nice characters to construct round. They’ve been via quite a bit these final three seasons, with way more forward of them from each acquainted and new foes as violence consumes the Continent, which you’re feeling within the smaller character moments as they navigate this new world.
Whereas this season includes quite a lot of strolling, scheming, and battles round settings which might be typically an unsightly grey coloration, the dependable three enliven the storylines that encompass them. The brand new crowd that Ciri falls in with affords not simply one thing extra darkly chaotic in a present that desperately wants this vitality, it additionally reveals a brand new aspect to her character. The place a lot else can really feel just like the present is stagnating and calling again to its earlier, higher days, this new storyline ensures viewers will keep invested.
Sadly, this typically feels secondary to the principle journey we noticed Geralt marching off on on the finish of the third season. Which, regrettably, brings us again to Hemsworth. It’s simple to want the present would simply depart him alone and give attention to the extra partaking characters elsewhere. As Hemsworth’s Geralt tries to search out Ciri and Yennefer, we spend an entire lot of time with a perpetually glowering fellow who simply doesn’t have the identical vary and spark that Cavill’s model did. It makes you miss the moments between Ciri, Yennefer, Jaskier and the unique Geralt that paid off their emotional bonds extra impactfully than something this time round.
There’s some enjoyable backwards and forwards available between his different fellow vacationers, led by Laurence Fishburne’s mysterious newcomer Regis, although you possibly can’t shake the sense that they’re doing all of the heavy lifting. Hemsworth is painfully one-note, feeling like a glorified cosplayer the place a as soon as pleasant character as soon as stood.
The place Cavill introduced an actual presence to the position — managing to be gruffly humorous in a single second and believably brutal within the subsequent — Hemsworth is simply an anchor across the whole expertise from which “The Witcher” can’t shake free. It’s not simply the actual particulars of the voice and the way in which he carried himself which might be misplaced, however that nothing substantive is being supplied to take their place. Whereas casting is definitely an artwork and this was a troublesome position to fill, Hemsworth appears like he was chosen nearly at random as there may be by no means a second the place he believably inhabits the character.
There is perhaps sufficient dynamic motion sequences right here and there to win some followers of the present over. Plus, it goes out on a excessive observe with a brutally grim ending that gives a extra promising trace of what’s subsequent within the ultimate season. However it simply isn’t sufficient to make you neglect the void that now exists on the present’s middle. Hemsworth’s Geralt can wield all of the magic and drink all of the potions on the planet, it nonetheless received’t assist this character come again to life.
“The Witcher” Season 4 is now streaming on Netflix.
