Dangerous pizza remains to be pizza, and for die-hard followers of Scott Cawthon’s viral horror video video games, “5 Nights at Freddy’s 2” needs to be satisfying sufficient. Nonetheless, swapping empty energy for actual creative gas (one thing the movie trade desperately wants proper now), Blumhouse’s fine-enough follow-up to its hit adaptation from 2023 seems and seems like a form of imitation cheese.
“5 Nights at Freddy’s 2” isn’t mimicking the sooner film a lot as it’s parroting the thought of style storytelling itself. That form of trope-laden, paint-by-numbers terror could be a robust promote for cinephiles with even newbie’s information of slasher canon, however judging by the unique’s film’s huge field workplace and ever-zealous fandom, it’ll nonetheless be “pizza” to them.
Cawthon tackles the script solo this time, largely to his haunted animatronics’ detriment. Director Emma Tammi returns as nicely, steering the star-studded forged — together with returners Josh Hutcherson, Elizabeth Lail, and Piper Rubio — like a fleet of bumper vehicles touring a street filled with plot holes. Intelligent winks to the video games and the digital tradition that’s erupted round them since (“Freddy’s” is especially in style on social media stay streams) can’t account for the disconnect between the story’s vexing supernatural mechanics and weak human coronary heart.
It’s been a 12 months since Mike (Hutcherson) agreed to work the night time shift at Freddy Fazbear Pizza, a creepy deserted restaurant with a darkish previous that’s illuminated within the new movie’s prologue set within the Eighties. Neither Mike nor his youthful sister Abby (Rubio) have been again to the disastrous scene of the primary movie since police officer/love curiosity Vanessa (Lail) helped them escape the misunderstood clutches of Freddy, Bonnie, Chica, Cunning, and Mr. Cupcake.
Solely evil some of the time, “Freddy’s” predominant sights used to run on good old style engineering. Lately, they’re incessantly inhabited by ghosts — all of them the spirits of youngsters who have been murdered by Vanessa’s deranged father, William Afton (Matthew Lillard). He’s lifeless now too, however Cawthon’s script resuscitates him by digging deeper into the paranormal lore of the villain and his pizzeria. Forcing the trauma-centric arcs too many horror survivors get saddled with at present, Mike and Vanessa face darkish desires that say their battle isn’t over.
Cute in a precocious and form of creepy manner, 11-year-old Abby is ok by comparability. Greater than coping nicely, she’s truly able to get again to Freddy’s. She sees the freakishly huge robots and the lifeless youngsters dwelling inside them (whose human names she doesn’t even know, by the way in which?) as “her pals.” They’re all offline now however the gang might be up and working simply as quickly as Abby convinces Mike to return and assist with the restore job.
In fact, Mike would like his little sister not be crushed by the possessed remnants of an off-brand Chuck E. Cheese and he says no. But it surely’s not lengthy earlier than the varsity science truthful convinces Abby she will be able to sort out the issue herself — it doesn’t matter what nasty factor her terrible robotics instructor Mr. Berg (Wayne Knight) has to say about her aptitude for STEM. Quickly, Abby is dashing into the night time on her bike headed for a Freddy’s go to you recognize has to finish badly.
The scene would appear ripped from “E.T.” or Stephen King’s “It” if it had any cinematic sensibility. Tammi’s imaginative and prescient as a director falters early and sometimes, following Cawthon’s muddy script by means of a careless puzzle that robs its characters of frequent sense and routinely returns them to an more and more uninteresting location the place they haven’t any compelling cause to be.
Sure, a younger lady wants pals and even hulking steel ones ought to depend for one thing. However Abby’s relationship to the deceased youngsters at Freddy’s by no means lands as honest, side-stepping the ethereal humanity of comparable scenes in motion pictures from “The Black Cellphone” to “Coraline,” making room for much more ham-fisted exposition. (Maddeningly direct and but infuriatingly complicated, this can be a good “second-screen” film as a result of it doesn’t make sense if you watch it both manner.)
A number of days earlier, a crew of paranormal investigators, helmed by the spunky Lisa (Mckenna Grace), got here to the restaurant and woke up a unique, extra malevolent presence lurking inside. Save for just a few additional blood spatters, the gore remains to be solely ever implied in “Freddy’s” and protecting all of the deadly motion offscreen will get outdated quick. A number of new characters from the video games — chief amongst them, a big marionette with a deeply unnerving face — carry simply sufficient curiosity to maintain your consideration for roughly half the function. The sequel is shorter than the unique movie, working 1 hour and 44 minutes. But it surely will get slower and worse because it goes.
Regardless of an admirable dedication to world-building, Cawthon doesn’t accomplish that nicely with the forged’s human additions. Lisa and Mr. Berg might’ve injected slightly extra enjoyable into Abby, Mike, and Vanessa’s surprisingly bleak story of restoration and revenge. However casting the “Seinfeld” legend previously generally known as Newman doesn’t end in a single humorous line from the beloved sitcom actor. As a substitute, the film squanders Knight’s expertise for supply and fingers him an ungainly slapstick bit that seems like work simply to look at.
Grace will get extra to do as Lisa however it’s simply not sufficient of the megawatt star, whose casting excited loads of non-“Freddy’s” followers prior to now. They’ll be disenchanted to see the actress egregiously sidelined, given restricted character improvement in an finally VFX-heavy half that treats her like a really costly, charismatic prop. Horror heads have been much more stoked to see Lillard and Skeet Ulrich — who performs the dad of a former Freddy’s sufferer — working collectively for the primary time since “Scream.” However the beloved Ghostface boys don’t get a scene collectively and their particular person talent units go to waste because of Tammi’s unusually timid path.
Editors Timothy Alverson and Derek Larsen do their job by at the very least maintaining the tempo, however cinematographer Lyn Moncrief doesn’t do “Freddy’s” any favors with the shot framing. Emotional moments fall flat and jump-scares go slack as actors are routinely pushed too removed from the lens, or worse, proven at such a extreme angle it hides a lot of their craft from view. Lillard specifically takes enormous swings throughout a hallucination sequence with Vanessa that will be a lot cooler if a tiny fraction of the anguish in his voice was adequately proven on display.
That mentioned, “5 Nights at Freddy’s 2” remains to be a serviceable step-up for all concerned. In case you favored the primary movie otherwise you’re a fan of the video games, you’ll have a good time at this one; thanks for coming to the films and shopping for these gigantic Fozzy popcorn buckets, actually! As for the remainder of you, skip this and go see “Bugonia” or one other of the 12 months’s finest motion pictures if you need extra severe creative nourishment. Nothing beats dangerous pizza like distinctive pizza, and also you’ll know the distinction when its served on display.
Grade: C-
From Blumhouse, “5 Nights at Freddy’s 2” is now enjoying in theaters.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the very best new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.
