Dr. Robby is caught. The E.R.’s attending doctor at Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Middle (performed by latest Emmy winner Noah Wyle) is one shift away from a much-needed trip. Formally dubbed a “sabbatical,” the great physician plans to spend his three-month tour(!) on the again of his new bike(!!) cruising throughout the northern United States — a dude-bro’s dream journey that doubles as a macho cowl for its delicate motivation: Dr. Robby’s pandemic-induced PTSD. Given he’s nonetheless overworked and under-supported all these years later, taking a bit “me time” to grieve and get his head proper feels like simply what the physician ordered.
However now there’s Dr. Baran Al-Hashim (Sepideh Moafi). Earlier than he can hop on his hog and experience off into the sundown, Dr. Robby has to verify his substitute is on top of things on his their the E.R.. Meaning not solely giving “Dr. Al” the lay of the land, however handing over the reins, which turns into a bit more durable to do when she begins implementing new insurance policies (“affected person passports”), preaching the advantages of synthetic intelligence (for sooner charting and administrative effectivity), and usually pushing the outgoing attendee out of her approach.
“The Pitt” Season 2 is way over simply Dr. Robby vs. Dr. Al. Whereas there’s a good bit of enjoyable available of their skilled pissing match — with an emphasis on “skilled,” because the dueling docs’ decorum by no means dips previous a curt acknowledgment right here or a passive rebuttal there — what their dynamic actually does is deepen the present’s superficial conceit: time. Whereas Dr. Robby is making an attempt to get via one final shift stuffed with the speedy calls for of sufferers in disaster, Dr. Al represents the larger image. Change is coming. How a lot change and the way lengthy isn’t but recognized, however whether or not it’s as brief as Dr. Robby’s sabbatical or so long as a profession amputated by A.I., everybody can really feel it coming.
For somebody like Dr. Robby, who’s as happy with his accomplishments within the E.R. as he’s determined for reinforcements, change is frightening. He needs to consider it would work out for the very best, however he’s skilled sufficient to have seen that hope get trampled time and time once more. And now, the stakes are increased. Along with all these operational modifications, he’s additionally making an attempt to vary himself.
Including these existential ticking clocks to a story that performs out in real-time is a intelligent means to amplify the suspense driving “The Pitt.” Similar to Season 1 and in contrast to so a lot of its friends, R. Scott Gemmill’s medical drama doesn’t dwell on melodramatic backstories, mysterious illnesses, or romantic subplots. Its urgency stems from the job’s incessant calls for, illustrated by the regular move of sufferers flooding The Pitt. (A short lived antagonist fairly than an precise enemy, Dr. Al desirous to kill off the discouraging nickname — aka, that she needs characters to cease utilizing the title of the present — could also be her most damning attribute.)
Accordingly, its satisfactions come from seeing these calls for met. “The Pitt’s” tense-yet-rousing escapism serves as drugs for the streaming-addled (or just stressed-out) mind. Witnessing leaders actually lead, like Dr. Robby does when rallying the troops or preventing for his employees? Watching professionals act professionally, like Dana (Emmy-winner Katherine LaNasa) does when treating a rape sufferer? Observing an onslaught of relatable setbacks get rectified by a sprawling group of people who find themselves barely hanging on, just like the residents and interns who’re solely simply beginning to glimpse life’s myriad inequities — and simply beginning to discover ways to proper them, each time they’ll? All this provides as much as an absorbing viewing expertise, which makes every episode a rewarding break from actuality.
Though that’s to not say “The Pitt” ignores actuality. Removed from it. Not solely do the lived-in performances and convincing dialogue hold issues grounded, Season 2 addresses topical points just like the A.I. invasion, malnutrition in prisons, the medical health insurance disaster, precarious cyber safety, poor human safety, and the unforgiving results of a rustic intent on working its residents to loss of life. Gemmill has described the E.R. as society’s security web, and Season 2 as soon as once more hooks a lot of society’s ills in its circumstances and character research. It acknowledges the hardships of dwelling via what seems like unprecedented occasions, whereas rooting each second in a actuality that’s as pressing as it’s acquainted.
Periodically, “The Pitt’s” relentless tempo can get the higher of its extra compact messaging. Too many episodes finish with arbitrary cliffhangers meant to propel you ahead, and too few hours in Dr. Robby’s shift really feel considerable on their very own. The unabated push ahead can override slighter episodic arcs, and the drab, unchanging hospital setting (whereas lifelike!) stays over-sanitized and uninviting. Collectively, these concessions to ahead momentum could make the answer to TV’s content material downside really feel a bit an excessive amount of like content material itself.
Nonetheless, a few of these foibles are simpler to forgive when seen in service of the higher good. Via 9 episodes, “The Pitt” Season 2 appears intent on confronting the consequence and temporality of the current. All the pieces Dr. Robby does in his shift carries huge ramifications for his sufferers, his colleagues, his hospital, and himself, and but, on the finish of the day, he’s nonetheless anticipated to punch out and stroll away from each a kind of issues. Can he do it? Can he settle for that he wants to do it? And may the system he’s established actually hold operating the best way it has to with out him?
“The Pitt” excels at discovering the common within the explicit, and Season 2 isn’t any totally different. Who amongst us hasn’t questioned if we’re replaceable? If we’re wanted? If after we handle ourselves, we’re not neglecting take care of others? The solutions could also be apparent, however enacting them is rarely simple. Via overwhelming competence, “The Pitt” evokes us to unstick ourselves — or I hope it would. Dr. Robby deserves a break.
Grade: B
“The Pitt’ Season 2 premieres Thursday, January 8 at 9 p.m. ET on HBO Max. New episodes might be launched weekly via the finale on April 16.
