Why Our Brains, Our Selves received the 2025 Royal Society Trivedi Science E-book Prize

Science books, particularly these written by scientists, generally have the repute of being dry, boring and tough. Maybe they’re regarded as thinly disguised textbooks, one thing to study from in a structured approach. The books on the shortlist for the Royal Society Trivedi Science E-book Prize are testomony to the fallacy of this view, and none extra so than the one the judges picked as this 12 months’s winner: Our Brains, Our Selves by neurologist Masud Husain.

I used to be lucky to be chair of a panel of six – all readers and lovers of books, together with New Scientist’s information editor Jacob Aron – who had the tough job of selecting the shortlist after which the ultimate total prizewinner. Composed of passionate advocates for science, our discussions had been wide-ranging and interesting, as you may count on of a set of people that love each science and books.

We regularly disagreed, at all times politely, and I’ve not often been with a set of people that listened so properly to opposing factors of view. Our very completely different beginning factors and lived experiences meant we realized a lot, each concerning the books we had been privileged to learn and about studying itself.

There have been many wonderful science books amongst this 12 months’s entries, however Our Brains, Our Selves stood out for its mixture of gorgeous storytelling, rigorous and cutting-edge science informed in an interesting approach, and, above all, its humanity. Husain is a neuroscientist, but additionally a clinician: seven of his sufferers’ tales make up the chapters of the guide.

Their circumstances differ – one particular person is overcome with apathy after surviving a stroke; one other believes she is having an affair together with her personal husband – however all of them result in profound modifications. The guide is a wonderful exploration of how pathological issues within the mind could cause folks to turn out to be utterly completely different, such that they’re rejected by society.

The golden thread working by means of the guide is the idea of “self” and the way the mind influences who we’re. It is vitally empathetic, informed in an exquisite approach and from a really private perspective. The science is all there too – a lot of it based mostly on Husain’s personal analysis, all defined very clearly, with the issues we don’t know nonetheless clearly highlighted. That is one thing I admire. Too usually we count on science to have all of the solutions, however actually the perfect science is the science that prompts us to ask the subsequent thrilling query.

The format of case research from a medical observe may appear tried and true, however the distinction right here is that golden thread, with a very private contact. Have you ever ever felt excluded from belonging? The tales of those sufferers with mind issues pressure the reader to consider id and the idea of self, and what “belonging” means to us each as people and as members of society.

That concept resonated with us as a panel. All of us thought-about, what does it imply to belong? A number of of the folks we meet within the guide are members of immigrant communities (as is the creator himself) who’ve needed to overcome prejudice, resentment and generally even violence to belong to the society through which they discovered themselves. As our world turns into ever extra linked, it appears logical that our concern of distinction must diminish, however sadly it appears that evidently isn’t the case.

Our Brains, Our Selves actually makes the reader take into consideration how issues of the mind could cause folks to alter profoundly such that they now not belong, but additionally how cognitive capabilities contribute to our personal identities. Our mind actually does decide who we’re. This very compassionate guide not solely effortlessly teaches the reader concerning the science however can also be stuffed with unimaginable human kindness.

Sandra Knapp is a plant taxonomist on the Pure Historical past Museum, London. She chaired the judging panel for this 12 months’s Royal Society Trivedi Science E-book Prize. The winner of the prize is Our Brains, Our Selves, the newest decide for the New Scientist E-book Membership.