Video assistant referee decisions spark debates weekly in the Premier League. Each season highlights key incidents, breaking down the VAR protocol and Laws of the Game to assess accuracy.
Arsenal 2-0 Everton: Missed Penalty in 23rd Minute
Arsenal pressed for a first-half penalty when Michael Keane stepped on Kai Havertz’s Achilles as the forward entered the penalty area. Referee Andy Madley waved away the appeals, and VAR Stuart Attwell upheld the on-field call.
The contact from Keane on Havertz registered as minimal, allowing the referee’s no-penalty decision to stand after review. Officials determined the incident did not significantly hinder Havertz’s momentum or shot opportunity.
VAR Analysis
Replays revealed a different picture from the real-time view. While the contact level was not severe, Keane’s step on the Achilles of the advancing Havertz—who was ahead of the defender—warranted a foul. This disrupted the attacker’s progress toward goal.
In real time, the clash appeared accidental, with both players moving similarly. However, video evidence showed Keane instigating the contact from behind. VAR protocol called for an on-field review, leading to a penalty award. The non-intervention raises questions about the decision-making process.
Chelsea Huddle and Referee Paul Tierney
A pre-match huddle by Chelsea in the center circle drew attention, with referee Paul Tierney positioned there holding the match ball. This practice, used by teams like Liam Rosenior’s side recently, placed Tierney amid the group.
Officials prepare for such routines, and Tierney anticipated Chelsea’s huddle ahead of Newcastle’s kick-off. His aim was proactive management to prevent opposition tensions. Yet, remaining over the ball as players encircled him escalated the moment unnecessarily.
Chelsea continued unfazed, likely briefed in pre-match discussions. Still, the visuals reflected poorly on match officials, the Premier League, and Tierney. Better positioning could have avoided the awkward optics entirely.
