Even earlier than Rian Johnson‘s much-anticipated third Knives Out thriller world premiered on the Toronto Worldwide Movie Pageant (as all of Johnson’s wily whodunits have), phrase was already out that this was a bit darker. In spite of everything, it’s proper there within the title, “Wake Up Lifeless Man,” which doesn’t fuss about with the truth that as enjoyable as these capers are, they’re nonetheless about murders. And Johnson himself didn’t shrink back from that early buzz, telling the group assembled on the Princess of Wales Theater on Saturday evening that, if “Knives Out” was a extra cozy thriller and “Glass Onion” was a much bigger, sunnier deconstruction of the style, “Wake Up Lifeless Man” was his dip into extra Edgar Allan Poe-tinged waters.
It really works, and it’s no large thriller why — Johnson is aware of his type and format, and delivers on it, enjoying with tone and message however by no means shedding sight of why these tales are so rattling entertaining to observe and unravel.
As ever, grasp detective Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig) is joined by a assassin’s row (oh, are they now? let’s see) of big-name abilities, although Josh O’Connor as younger priest Jud Duplenticy steals the present as a terrified homicide suspect who involves accomplice with Benoit. Johnson has at all times been aces at casting, however he’s right here given rising star O’Connor a particular function: each darkish and humorous, determined and in management. When the movie actually flips its tone about midway by way of, O’Connor ably carries that twist. (And, no, we doubt another younger working actor might so winkingly ship a line about being “younger, dumb, and filled with Christ” fairly just like the multi-faceted O’Connor.)
Whereas we don’t see Benoit for the primary half hour of the movie — at simply over two hours and 21 minutes, the movie nonetheless strikes at a zippy clip — audiences might be naturally inclined to do some clue-gathering in his stead, all the higher to be on the identical web page because the detecting genius when he arrives. Aided by voiceover narration by Jud (within the type of a letter, and guess to whom!), we shortly be taught the lay of the land: the younger priest was referred to as to the church after a rebellious youth as a brawling boxer, one thing referred to as the Good Friday Homicide has simply occurred, and Jud is totally up his neck with weirdo potential baddies.
Newly shipped off to a small congregation in Chimney Rock, New York, Jud has spent the previous 9 months attempting to navigate his means by way of some nutty church politics. (The movie’s upstate setting remembers “Knives Out,” and is each cozy and sinister, grand outdated church buildings with big marble crypts behind them will do this.) They’ve gotten a complete lot worse within the face of a stunning and seemingly unsolvable homicide, which Benoit arrives to attempt to crack. Who else would so fortunately signal as much as decide aside a “completely unattainable crime”? And who wouldn’t again down as its parts get darker and deeper, grimmer and weirder?
The church’s head — Monsignor Jefferson Wicks (Josh Brolin), please, not merely “Father Wicks” — inherited his grandfather’s calling and has spent the previous few years bringing collectively a small, however very devoted flock. All of them are suspects: longtime worker Martha (Glenn Shut), her boyfriend and the church’s handyman Samson (Thomas Haden Church), pissy lawyer Vera (Kerry Washington), her wannabe political influencer adopted son Cy (Daryl McCormack), MAGA-ish writer Lee (Andrew Scott), cuckolded native physician Nat (Jeremy Renner), and the determined former cellist Simone (Cailee Spaeny).
Because the movie winds on, we be taught each the depth of the congregation’s dedication to Wicks and the discomfiting nature of his preaching. The product of a “harlot whore” mom (Annie Hamilton in flashbacks), Wicks has slowly gathered collectively a loyal cadre of followers who see worth in his messaging, which is usually involved with preserve undesirables very a lot out and leaning on the type of God-fearing ideas far too obsessive about the fearing half.
All of his favorites are one way or the other aggrieved by their lot in life, and Wicks’ firebrand methods enchantment to their sense of justice and vengeance, even when none of their worries are rooted in something all that actual. Disinformation reigns supreme of their suggestions loops, outsiders are dangerous, the outdated methods are greatest, and at the least certainly one of them earnestly asks, “What’s fact?”
You may see the place that is all going, although Johnson, who additionally wrote the movie’s script, leans arduous into the current-day, well timed connections — if these individuals might begin their very own social media platform simply to evangelise about Wicks they might, however for now, YouTube should do — earlier than easing up the fuel only a bit. These mysteries have at all times been about storytelling, what individuals share, what they don’t, and what they need to be seen for. Jud muses that mendacity isn’t actually vital, simply omit the the stuff that’s not true, and Wicks and his band of brainwashed rageaholics (Scott’s character has actually constructed a moat round his home) have taken that to wild, fervent ends.
How do you battle religion and perception? For somebody like Benoit, so steeped in rationality, so comfortable to announce he’s a heretic whereas actually standing in a church, the query couldn’t be tougher to reply. Fortunately, Johnson and his solid are greater than up for the duty, guiding “Wake Up Lifeless Man” by way of all of the requisite twists and turns, ups and downs, revelations and Revelations. Tales are spun after which instantly tied again up into knots, and its gothic drama supplies a contemporary new place for Johnson to play in his most well-liked style.
As blunt as a few of its up to date inspirations would possibly really feel within the second — although Cy’s hilariously terrible love of posting and his horrifying YouTube account (full with Wicks’ sermons about every part from “non-binary being non-godly” to “there’s GOD in DOGE”) — Johnson, Benoit, and Jud are extra involved with taking us by way of basic issues and caveats. What does it imply to imagine one thing that appears unattainable, to see issues nobody else can, to attract connections between disparate issues, and to inform tales about all of that? On the earth of Knives Out, it’s a matter of each religion and leisure, and it’s simple to get ecstatic about each.
Grade: B+
“Wake Up Lifeless Man” premiered on the 2025 Toronto Worldwide Movie Pageant. Netflix will launch it in choose theaters on Wednesday, November 26 and on its streaming platform on Friday, December 12.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Overview by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up one of the best new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.
