Karl Marx himself could have written that “historical past repeats itself, first as tragedy, second as farce.” Nonetheless, not even probably the most devoted members of Japan’s Pink Military Faction — a militant, “Communist Manifesto”-carrying group most well-known for hijacking a JAL flight within the spring of 1970 — may have imagined their signature motion would ultimately be restaged as a slick and sprawling Netflix comedy combining the smirking political satire of “Burn After Studying” with the cold-blooded visible dynamism of a Park Chan-wook movie.
Positive, the Yodogo Hijacking Incident wasn’t fairly a tragedy, and “Good Information” is only a bit too grounded to really feel like a real farce, however the disconnect between the severity of what occurred and the blitheness with which Korean director Byun Sung-hyun (“The Cruel”) has re-imagined it’s putting sufficient to affirm Marx’s level. I’ve to think about that the hijackers would’ve been joyful about that; bumbling and inept as they seem in Byun’s film, their conviction smacks of braveness when in comparison with the spinelessness of the bureaucrats tasked with fixing the disaster, all of whom care extra about their very own egos and careers than they do the 130 passengers whose lives are at stake.
Simply droll, twisty, and trendy sufficient to forgive this 136-minute movie for utilizing much more runway than it must be airborne, “Good Information” is a veritable caricature of middle-management — an epic parody of passing the buck. That so few of the particular information have been modified, regardless of an impishly self-conflicting disclaimer that insists it was “impressed by actual occasions” but in addition that “all the characters and occasions portrayed are fictional,” solely serves to strengthen Byun’s damning portrayal of political cowardice.
For all the lip service that Byun and Lee Jin-seong’s knotted script pays to the relative nature of reality, nonetheless, “Good Information” initially makes it simple to separate truth from fiction. Did closely armed hijackers commandeer a Boeing 727 as a part of their plan to additional a worldwide revolution in opposition to the USA and its allies? Certainly, and a gap flurry of newsreel footage helps to verify that we aren’t fully exterior of historical past. Did the Communists obsessively quote the boxing manga “Ashita no Joe” as a supply of inspiration? Was their chief as good-looking as “Tokyo Vice” star Present Kasamatsu, or their youngest member barely sufficiently old to fly with out parental supervision? Most likely not.
Did the disaster spotlight the Kafkaesque absurdity of Chilly Warfare politics by sparking a world circle-jerk between numerous representatives from South Korea, North Korea, Japan, America, and the Soviet Union? You wager. Did the South Koreans depend on the assistance of a rumpled and mysterious fixer referred to as “No one” (a Lupin the III-esque Sul Kyung-gu, his character clever sufficient to deal with the entire scenario like a cosmic joke) to goad everybody into motion? I extremely doubt it, however historical past tends to overlook the individuals who refuse to just accept credit score for it. Ditto those that handle to keep away from taking the blame.
“Good Information” has loads of enjoyable exaggerating the personas of the completely different events concerned within the scenario, from the violent JAL chairman who solely cares about his model, to the veteran airplane pilot who can’t cease complaining about his hemorrhoids, and the Korean Central Intelligence Company Director (Ryoo Seung-bum) who tries to scrub his palms of this complete shitshow like a used automobile salesman determined to maneuver an outdated lemon off the lot. However the film solely actually takes flight after the road between “tragedy” and “farce” begins to blur, like when a proactive air pressure “double parks” a jet in entrance of the 727 because it stops to refuel. (The visible of the 2 planes going through one another on the tarmac because the pilot scampers away from his automobile is an actual laugh-out-loud second in a film that tends to fall again on realizing smiles.)
Humorous as it’s, that sequence pales compared to what occurs later, when a younger Korean Air Pressure lieutenant named Search engine marketing (Hong Kyung) has the brilliant concept of executing a double hijack. The Pink Military Faction believes they’re flying into Pyongyang, however Search engine marketing — in a standoff that’s shot like a Sergio Leone spaghetti western, full with ultra-wide framing, skintight leather-based chaps, and some errant tumbleweeds for good measure — wrests management of the radio frequency from his North Korean counterparts and fools the hijackers into touchdown in Seoul’s Gimpo Worldwide Airport as a substitute.
Remarkably, this a part of the story is rooted in reality. Gimpo actually was rapidly outfitted to resemble Pyongyang within the hopes that the hijackers would imagine they’d succeeded. Byun merely “sure ands” the file by imagining that an obese native film director was recruited to finish the phantasm with a fleet of costumed extras ready for the Pink Military Faction on the “North Korean” runway. Like everybody else on this film, nonetheless, the director needs to border this story on his personal phrases (“If I can’t seize this historic second on movie, I at the very least need to take part in it!”), and his eagerness to manage the motion dangers creating new battle.
Not solely does this show of egomaniacal buffoonery make for “Good Information”’ only setpiece, the sheer absurdity of the scenario embellished by Byun’s arch framing and beforehand unknown aptitude for dry comedy, it additionally epitomizes the core ethos of a movie by which shaping the narrative is at all times extra essential than saving the hostages. Even the comparatively noble and clear-headed Search engine marketing is motivated by the legacy of his father’s sacrifice, which complicates his emotions in regards to the worth of heroism even because it pushes him to take advantage of his second within the limelight.
“Good Information” has no compunctions about depicting its characters — even and particularly the South Korean ones — as narcissistic dolts. However these larger-than-life figures are as broad as their context is hyper-specific. That practical mismatch saps away on the comedy of a movie clearly made to be loved by a world viewers. (Netflix is releasing it all over the world on the identical time, and the multi-language audio monitor will unhelpfully default to English for anybody who tries to stream the film from America.) Pointed gestures towards the lingering stress between Japan and Korea — and between these two international locations and the remainder of the planet — are drowned out by tiresome bickering and exaggerated gags, like a significant dialog swallowed into the sound of an airplane engine screaming overhead.
Byun’s visible playfulness is likewise compelling sufficient to compensate for the shortcuts in his storytelling — lively camerawork and ingenious CGI mix with Jo Hyoung-rae’s heightened cinematography to imbue the movie’s airplane cabins and flight management towers with a vivid sense of theatricality. But the director is so wanting to make a spectacle out of this situation that “Good Information” begins to really feel as self-insistent as its characters.
Maybe that’s by design, and Byun is bending his personal kind in direction of a damning commentary on common self-interest — even within the face of a disaster. However the film’s soft-hearted underbelly fails to help that studying, and by the point the story lastly arrives at its closing moments, the unsparing cynicism that provided its preliminary elevate has been dragged again right down to Earth by the burden of bland truisms. In a wealthy however more and more disappointing movie the place everyone seems to be making an attempt so exhausting to go the buck, it’s solely becoming that viewers find yourself holding the bag.
Grade: C+
“Good Information” might be accessible to stream on Netflix beginning Friday, October 17.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the most effective new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.
