An Australian lady, who was sentenced to life in jail with a non-parole interval of 33 years for poisoning 4 and killing three of her estranged husband’s kinfolk with demise cap mushrooms, has filed an enchantment to overturn her conviction.
In July, a jury discovered Erin Patterson, 52, responsible of murdering three kinfolk of her estranged husband and trying to homicide a fourth within the state of Victoria in 2023.
Patterson might be 82 years outdated when she turns into eligible for parole in November 2056, however paperwork launched Wednesday by the Supreme Court docket of Victoria confirmed Patterson filed an software for depart to enchantment her conviction on Monday.
Within the paperwork, seen by Reuters, the seven grounds of enchantment included {that a} “basic irregularity” occurred whereas the jury was sequestered. Native media, citing the court docket, reported the jurors stayed in the identical resort as police and prosecutors for almost all of their deliberations.
“That has fatally undermined the integrity of the verdicts and requires the quashing of the convictions and an order for a re-trial in order that justice can’t solely be executed however be seen to be executed,” the paperwork mentioned.
Patterson additionally claimed that numerous items of proof launched, together with cell tower location information and messages from Fb associates, have been “unfairly prejudicial” or “irrelevant.”
Moreover, Patterson claimed a “substantial miscarriage of justice occurred” as a result of prosecution’s “unfair and oppressive” cross-examination of her when she gave proof over the a number of days of the trial.
She steered the prosecution’s opening and shutting arguments additionally induced a “substantial miscarriage of justice,” as a result of they launched a motive for homicide throughout their closing handle however the Crown opened its case alleging no motive.
Get breaking Nationwide information
For information impacting Canada and world wide, join breaking information alerts delivered on to you after they occur.
Patterson additionally claimed that Justice Christopher Beale, who was the decide appointed to her trial, had “erred” by not permitting pictures and movies “associated to mushrooms” that have been discovered at Patterson’s home to be put earlier than the jury.
The enchantment paperwork says that Patterson is a prisoner at Dame Phyllis Frost Centre and doesn’t wish to attend the enchantment listening to in particular person, however would like a video look as a substitute.
The state of Victoria’s Court docket of Attraction mentioned that whereas Patterson’s enchantment had been lodged, it had not but been accepted as of Wednesday.
Patterson was convicted of killing her mother-in-law Gail Patterson, father-in-law Donald Patterson and Gail’s sister Heather Wilkinson in a case that gripped the nation and drew worldwide consideration for its uncommon circumstances.
The jury of 12 discovered she lured them to lunch at her dwelling in Leongatha, a city of about 6,000 folks, and poisoned them with beef Wellingtons containing demise cap mushrooms.
She was additionally discovered responsible of the tried homicide of Ian Wilkinson, Heather’s husband, who survived the 2023 meal.
Beale advised the Victoria state Supreme Court docket that Patterson’s crimes concerned an unlimited betrayal of belief.
“Your victims have been all of your kinfolk by marriage. Greater than that, that they had all been good to you and your youngsters over a few years, as you acknowledged in your testimony,” Beale mentioned.
“Not solely did you chop quick three lives and trigger lasting injury to Ian Wilkinson’s well being, thereby devastating prolonged Patterson and Wilkinson households, you inflicted untold struggling by yourself youngsters, whom you robbed of their beloved grandparents,” Beale added.
The decide advised Patterson that solely she is aware of “why you dedicated” the crimes.
Patterson confirmed little emotion throughout her sentencing listening to in September and stored her eyes closed for a lot of it.
Prosecution and defence attorneys each agreed {that a} life sentence was an acceptable punishment for Patterson on three counts of homicide and considered one of tried homicide.
Defence attorneys had requested for Patterson to turn into eligible for parole after serving 30 years however prosecutors argued she ought to by no means be thought of for parole as a result of she didn’t deserve the court docket’s mercy.
In Canada, demise cap mushrooms are current in lots of B.C.’s forests however may be present in metropolis environments related to many species of imported bushes. In line with the B.C. Centre for Illness Management, the mushrooms have been noticed on Vancouver Island and within the Decrease Mainland.
Demise cap mushrooms look just like widespread puffball mushrooms, however ought to by no means be eaten. When you suspect you’ll have consumed a demise cap mushroom, it is best to search emergency medical care instantly.
Signs of being poisoned by a demise cap mushroom embody low blood strain, nausea and vomiting.
— With information from Reuters
© 2025 International Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.
