Al Carns, the Labour MP for Birmingham Selly Oak, stands out among the 2024 election newcomers due to his distinguished military service. Elected in a Labour landslide, he became one of only two Commons members holding a gallantry medal, the Military Cross. Carns left the armed forces just days before a promotion to brigadier, opting instead for the challenges of Westminster politics.
Military Expertise Leads to Key Role
His undisclosed special forces experience quickly elevated him to a ministerial position overseeing veterans’ affairs. Veterans from various backgrounds, including former Conservative MPs, praise his handling of the role. This appointment underscores his credibility in defense matters, addressing perceptions of the party’s patriotism.
Recent Encounters Highlight Charisma
In a Whitehall event, discussions with Carns revealed his approachable nature. Sharing military service histories, the conversation covered transitions from the forces, the Strategic Defence Review, and other defense topics. Fresh from a record-breaking Mount Everest ascent in under five days without acclimatization—which he termed a “lick”—Carns demonstrated sharpness and engagement on his portfolio.
Strengths for Broader Appeal
Carns’ military record counters criticisms of lacking national pride; he served under the flag and mourned comrades who did the same. This background could attract young male voters, a demographic targeted by Reform UK, especially online, while resonating in traditional Labour areas valuing military respect. Observers note he would challenge figures like Nigel Farage effectively, unlike potential rivals such as Ed Miliband, Wes Streeting, or Angela Rayner.
Potential Hurdles in Leadership Race
Despite these assets, Carns’ likeability and communication skills may hinder internal party support. Labour’s history favors candidates appealing to trade unions, activists, and the metropolitan left over those with broad public charisma, as seen with past leaders like Keir Starmer, Jeremy Corbyn, Ed Miliband, and Gordon Brown. Current speculation positions Miliband as a frontrunner if Andy Burnham misses a parliamentary seat, despite Burnham’s past leadership losses and -32 net approval rating per YouGov.
Carns’ focus on Ministry of Defence issues leaves his views on other policies unclear, offering a blank slate but risking scrutiny. His military past, a general election strength, might alienate the party’s pacifist wing in a leadership contest.
